Which Roger Lewis do we believe?

In November 2012, Roger Lewis said:

“I personally negotiated a television deal for them in respect of the Celtic League, or the RaboDirect Pro12 as it is now. Together with the money from European tournaments – and I’ve spent six years on the European Rugby Cup board ensuring income is maximised – that realises £9m a year. ”

Or last Monday, from the minutes of the supporters’ meeting with Roger Lewis and the WRU:

“RL went on to say that the latest RRW statement (regarding, amongst others, the TV revenues) was, at a minimum, misleading. and contained confidential information which should not have been disclosed. He stated that it was not the WRU or himself that negotiated TV deals but Celtic League Ltd and ERC Ltd, of which the Regions had been party to.”