A couple of weeks ago, the WRU sent this letter outlining more planned changes to the structure of the middle and lower leagues in Wales.
There are several problems with the proposal:
- They need an extra 24 refs for the new Div 1 and 2 – these will be drawn from Level 2 refs currently reffing Youth/2nd team rugby
- Teams currently in Div 6 will play teams from current Div 3/4 next season. These means a lot of mismatches and dilution of quality of the games
- Has this been agreed by the WRU Head of Rugby and Head of Refs? If it hasn’t, what does that say about the way the WRU is behaving?
This will undoubtedly lead to a lot of smaller clubs getting pissed off with having beatings dished out to them by much better teams on a regular basis. Many of these clubs and their players may just give up. This doesn’t seem to be a very sensible approach for the WRU to be adopting at a time when they need to bolster their support at grassroots level instead of alienating it.
To all Referee Society Secretaries and P.B. Executive
Following on from last Friday nights Parent Body meeting where we discussed next years league and fee structures I have listed below a number of bullet points for further discussion with your members, which we discussed at the meeting.
- As stated on Friday, next season (2014-15) we have a potential increase of games from 126 this season to 155 next season
- The number of officials at Level 3 will increase from approx. 150 to 180 in order to service the increase
- The lowest league proposed for next season is Division 3 which will be regionalised
- Divisions 1 & 2 will become 4 divisions within each. Currently these are 1E & W and 2E & W.
- There will be obvious dilution in the quality of games within these two leagues
- A third division being created in North Wales will add extra cost. When you consider it costs the department approximately 200/230 pounds to send a referee to NW or vice versa to SW.
- We will need an extra 24 referees to referee at Div 1 & 2 next season
- Our development pathway will be eroded in as much as Level 2 referees will now move straight from Youth/Second team rugby to Division 3
- If the fee structure were to stay the same (up to Dev 3 which will be the lowest league next season) there is a potential budget increase of £41880.00. This will be in match fees only. This does not account for mileage which is somewhat of an uncontrollable
- With the proposal that I have put forward which I believe is a fair and responsible one we will still have an increase of £21110.00
- There will be an obvious number of mismatches next season when Div 6 teams come up against teams from Div 3 / Div 4
Just to put you in the picture for those who are not familiar with next year’s league structure and how it will look I have outlined below.
Premiership – no structural change
Championship – no structural change
Division 1 – 4 leagues of 12 clubs, which will consist of the current 24 clubs in Division 1 plus the 24 clubs in Division 2 (league based on geography)
Division 2 – 4 leagues of 12 clubs, which will consist of the current 48 clubs from Division 3 (League based on geography)
Division 3 – There will be 13 Divisions consisting of the 48 clubs from Division 4, the 60 clubs from Division 5 and the 39 clubs from Division 6 (the 147 clubs will be assigned a league dependant on geography)
Division 1 N – 12 clubs
Division 2 N – 10 clubs
Division 3 N – 10 clubs
I hope the above gives you a bit more of an insight into the challenges that lie ahead and as always if there are any queries please do not hesitate to call me. As stated I have to factor in the dilution of the system and quality of the rugby that will be played in certain leagues next season.
I look forward to your response in early February as outlined in the meeting. By then we can hopefully work together and move this amended structure forward.